- In Modi, Trump has a leader he can truly work with: experts
- Monsoon session of Parliament from July 17 to Aug 11
- Over 140 people feared buried in China landslide
- Modi to be first world leader to have WH dinner with Trump
- DU announces first cut-off list
- Srikanth reaches 3rd successive Super Series final
- Modi embarks on three-nation tour
Proud moment re-visited
Controversy apart, Airlift revives forgotten tales
On its way to the coveted 100-crore club,Airlift has evidently won the hearts and minds of cine-goers, having made the most of the Republic Day patriotic fervor. But many are asking: To what extent is the film, which depicts the large-scale war-time evacuation of 1.70 lakh Indians from Kuwait in 1990, an accurate reflection of the event? The Ministry of External Affairs has put out an official statement saying that the film has been poorly researched and doesn't do justice to the Herculean effort that South Block put in to carry out what remains till date the largest civilian evacuation effort. Former diplomats have also reiterated this view, and even some civilians, who were part of the evacuation process, have shared their opinion on how the film strays from the reality that they had experienced.
On the other end of the spectrum, the film-makers have painstakingly sought to underline that an event such as this always has multiple perspectives and narratives, andAirlift tells one story from the point of view of one character — Ranjit Katyal played by actor Akshay Kumar. Katyal's character is inspired by Mr Mathunny Mathews, then an influential Indian businessman in Kuwait who used his local contacts to help organise the evacuation. There is, of course, much dramatisation, and Katyal's character has, no doubt, been lionised. The debate is essentially over the degree to which Katyal's heroics inAirlift overshadow the good work done by others in real life. Given the impact of a major Hindi film production on public perception, this, understandably, has become somewhat of a contentious issue.
And more so since this is the first time that many young Indians are learning about this absolutely incredible feat. Of course, everybody knows that film-makers take liberty with the truth, and the reality is often not half as exciting or glamorous as depicted on-screen. Still, when the public has no other benchmark or reference point, it is inclined to accept whatever version of reality it has access to as some representation of the truth. This is possibly what has irked the MEA, which has arguably received a raw deal in the film. Still, even the ministry acknowledges that every film-maker is allowed his creative licence and, overall, has taken a balanced view of the matter.
But this controversy notwithstanding, Airlift deserves full credit for at least starting the conversation about this evacuation effort, which happened only two decades ago but had already been forgotten. Perhaps, the MEA's Public Diplomacy department should use this opportunity to commission a documentary on the episode, and indeed the many other evacuations that India has carried out over the years and across continents. Similarly, other film-makers too can follow suit and pick up the other stories that are waiting to be told from these operations — be they of Indian Government officials, evacuees or even foreign diplomats and leaders who may be involved.
- A Monsoon Requiem for Times Long Past 25 Jun 2017 | Kanchan Gupta | in Coffee Break
- Understanding Yoga 25 Jun 2017 | Pramod Pathak | in Spirituality
- Taiwan’s international isolation continues 25 Jun 2017 | Rajaram Panda | in Backbone
- Stability that matters for Chinese economy 24 Jun 2017 | Priyanka Pandit | in Oped
- Indian mediation in Korean War 24 Jun 2017 | Jagannath Panda | in Oped
- Widening fault lines in West Asia 24 Jun 2017 | Makhan Saikia | in Oped
- Now, a symbolic contest 24 Jun 2017 | Pioneer | in Edit
- Waiting for chemistry 24 Jun 2017 | Pioneer | in Edit
- What is being done is clearly not enough 24 Jun 2017 | Hiranmay Karlekar | in Edit
- A pleasant surprise from Honda 23 Jun 2017 | Kushan Mitra | in Automobile