Opp slams Goyal for ‘belittling’ Abhijit

| | Kolkata
  • 0

Opp slams Goyal for ‘belittling’ Abhijit

Saturday, 19 October 2019 | Saugar Sengupta | Kolkata

For those of you who have seen the new Rs 100 note, you would have noticed that there is a stepwell featured on it. Stepwells are a common feature across many parts of western India and were commonly used by Rajput kings and their predecessors in the earliest example of rainwater harvesting. Many of them have fallen into disrepair and disuse though they were all ornate at one time. Many, because they were often associated with religion, were destroyed when invading armies came into the region. But not the stepwell we see on the Rs 100 note. The Rani Ki Vav at Patan, Gujarat, survived thanks to it being covered in sand and mud.

Whether that was a deliberate act to protect it from armies that raided the prosperous traders of Gujarat is unknown, but it survived. It was not affected by the large-scale loot of antiquities by colonial powers thanks to it being lost in time and it was not “discovered” until after Independence and excavated in 1958.

We might criticise the Archeological Survey of India (ASI) for several things, including the large-scale “disappearance” of historical monuments in a city like New Delhi but it must be complimented for the astounding work it has done in restoring the Rani Ki Vav, which is a major reason that UNESCO made it a world heritage site. However, if there is any criticism of the ASI, it is that there can be much more information on the importance of the gods and goddesses of the Hindu pantheon, who have been painstakingly carved in three-dimensional ways into the stone. This site is a tremendous validation of the skills of craftsmen from Gujarat.

There is also the spectacular Surya Mandir in Modhera an hour from Patan, with its 12 carved “adityas” or manifestations inside, which is a must-visit. Both the well and the temple were built during the rule of Bhima I, the founder of the great Solanki dynasty, the well being built by his consort, Queen Udaymati. These sites, just a couple of hours from Ahmedabad, are a reminder of not only the great wealth of this part of the nation, which is as true now as it was then, but also the skill and patience of the rulers and the people.

It is a crying shame that there are fewer and fewer people taking up some of these intricate crafts. The Patola saris of Patan for example, with geometrical designs inspired by patterns on the vav, and the “double-ikat” method, requiring an understanding of complex mathematics, used to be made by 200 families.

The Bengal political parties and civil society have slammed Union Minister Piyush Goyal for attacking Nobel Laureate Abhijit Banerjee for his alleged Leftist leanings.

Faulting Goyal for, “unnecessarily bringing politics to malign a Nobel Laureate who has made India proud” Bengal Congress leader and MP Pradip Bhattacharya on Friday said “it is unfortunate that our Ministers are so uneducated and biased that they do not even think twice to belittle a Nobel Laureate who has made India proud by unnecessarily brining politics to malign him.”

Scoffing at Goyal he said, “the literacy level of our Ministers is so high that they do not even think twice to invoke Newton’s second law in Albert Einstein’s name,” and wondered “why a stalwart will have to be belittled just because he has Left leanings.”

Earlier while congratulating Abhijit for his remarkable achievements in the field of economics Goyal said, “I congratulate Abhijit Banerjee for winning the Nobel Prize … (but) you all know that his thinking is totally Left-leaning.” He backed his comments by saying how “Banerjee supported Nyay (poverty alleviation scheme of the Congress) but people of India rejected that ideology.”

Questioning Goyal’s “political wisdom” the Congress MP said “just because a political party got a mandate and another party did not get it you get the license to negate a Nobel Laureate’s scholarly findings. It is a political party that got the people’s mandate and not the theory of ‘Nyay’ which was supported by Abhijit Banerjee,” he said.

“Considering the sliding economic condition of the country during the BJP’s rule the time is coming when the people who are attacking day will go to him and sit at his feet to take lessons on economic development,” he maintained.

Bangla poet Subodh Ghosh also attacked Goyal for “failing to understand Banerjee’s achievements as an economist.” He said “it is irrelevant whether the Nyay found political success or not. The question is whether the prescription of Banerjee which has won him the Nobel Prize is relevant and affective in conquering poverty.”

Economist and State Financial Advisor Abhiroop Sarkar said, “it is unfortunate that someone of Abhijit Banerjee’s strature will get such reception from the national government.”Today just three Salvi families are in the trade. But Patola saris are still in demand while the kite-makers of Jamalpur in Ahmedabad are not so much, their creations being supplanted by cheap Chinese imports. These are also vital handicraft skills that we must all do more to preserve.

The Hyundai Venue has been a boon considering  the roads around Patan and Modhera are a bit on the poor side. There were roadworks ongoing but the car negotiated the tough rides without a problem. And even after covering 700 plus kilometres over two days on both highways and urbanised areas, the Venue diesel that is being driven returned an astounding fuel economy of over 21 kilometres a litre and has proven its maneuverability through the narrow lanes of the old city of Ahmedabad.

 

State Editions

AAP declares candidates for April 26 Mayoral polls

19 April 2024 | Staff Reporter | Delhi

BJP banks on Modi, uses social media to win voters

19 April 2024 | Saumya Shukla | Delhi

Sunita all set to participate in INDIA Bloc rally in Ranchi

19 April 2024 | Staff Reporter | Delhi

Woman boards bus in undergarments; travellers shocked

19 April 2024 | Staff Reporter | Delhi

Bullet Rani welcomed by BJP Yuva Morcha after 65 days trip

19 April 2024 | Staff Reporter | Delhi

Two held for killing man in broad daylight

19 April 2024 | Staff Reporter | Delhi

Sunday Edition

Astroturf | Reinvent yourself during Navaratra

14 April 2024 | Bharat Bhushan Padmadeo | Agenda

A DAY AWAITED FOR FIVE CENTURIES

14 April 2024 | Biswajeet Banerjee | Agenda

Navratri | A Festival of Tradition, Innovation, and Wellness

14 April 2024 | Divya Bhatia | Agenda

Spiritual food

14 April 2024 | Pioneer | Agenda

Healthier shift in Navratri cuisine

14 April 2024 | Pioneer | Agenda

SHUBHO NOBO BORSHO

14 April 2024 | Shobori Ganguli | Agenda