Assuming a real deal in Korea
As the proposed North Korea-US summit goes through many twists and turns, what would be the outcome if the meeting actually takes place? Kim Jong-un would gain a lot. What Trump needs is a diplomatic triumph that feeds his ego and maybe gets him the Nobel Peace Prize
The summit is on, it’s off, it’s sort of on again. It’s amateur night every night at the White House and the fate of the US-North Korean summit scheduled for Singapore on June 12 will be decided by the coin Donald Trump flips each day: Heads three days in a row means ‘yes’, tails three days in a row and the meeting stays cancelled. So let’s not waste time speculating on the unknowable. Let us just assume that the meeting between US President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un actually goes ahead in the end.
What would be a good outcome that stays within the bounds of plausibility? One that avoids a nuclear war, obviously, but it is equally obvious that neither party is going to abandon its nuclear weapons. The US, as the first country to build nuclear bombs and the only country ever to use them, sees having thousands of them as its birthright and would never consider giving them up. North Korea’s regime has only a few, but sees them as the only real guarantee of its survival.
But that can’t be entirely true because North Korea already survived for 57 years before it tested its first nuclear explosive device in 2006. It was another dozen years before it built a very small but theoretically effective force of nuclear-tipped ballistic missiles that could, on a good day and with a tail-wind, reach the US. Only now has Pyongyang achieved nuclear deterrence against the US. What protected it before that? What served North Korea as deterrence until 2017 was a very big Army (twice the size of South Korea’s Army plus the American troops stationed in South Korea), and the ability to destroy Seoul within a day or two using only conventional artillery and rockets.
Seoul’s northern suburbs are only 50 km from the North Korean border, well within the range of many thousands of North Korean artillery pieces and the metropolitan area is home to half of South Korea’s 50 million people. As the capital, it also contains almost all Government Ministries and military headquarters. Not even the US nuclear weapons could save it from destruction in a North-South war.
So forget about both sides’ nuclear weapons and concentrate on the conventional balance. South Korea has twice the population of North Korea but only half as many soldiers on active service because Seoul would rather save money and rely on (American-supplied) nuclear deterrence. Now that North Korea has nukes of its own, it too can afford to shrink its Army by at least half. In fact, it can’t really afford not to.
Kim Jong-un would gain a lot if the summit actually happens. Just by sitting down with a US President as an equal, he would win the kind of international legitimacy that always eluded his father and grandfather. If he also got an American promise not to try to overthrow him and a suspension of the US economic sanctions, his success would be complete. But what could he offer the US and South Korea in return?
Kim already unilaterally suspended both nuclear weapons testing and further ballistic missile flight tests in order to attract Trump to the table, but he must come up with some other concessions to get the rest of what he wants. How about a deal that commits him to reduce North Korea’s Army to the same size as South Korea’s and an agreement by both sides to move their artillery at least 50 km back from the inter-Korean border?
That sort of deal would save Kim a lot of money without exposing him to any serious risk: It’s his secret police, not the Army that keeps his population in line. South Korea would still have no credible ability to attack the North and Kim’s own ability to threaten Seoul with a “sea of fire” would evaporate because he would first have to move his artillery back to the border area along roads totally exposed to the US and South Korean air power.
This is what successful diplomatic deals look like. They are often asymmetric in some details but are more or less balanced overall and they give both parties what they need. What Trump needs is a diplomatic triumph that feeds his ego and maybe gets him the Nobel Peace Prize, while giving him a plausible excuse not to insist on the unattainable goal of eliminating North Korea’s rudimentary nukes and Intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM).
Kim can afford to give him concessions on other military issues because even a 10 per cent chance that one North Korean ICBM could deliver one nuclear weapon on an American city is deterrent enough to preclude any US attack on North Korea. In return, North Korea gets an end to sanctions and huge savings on its bloated military spending.
No promises, but this actually could happen. And if Trump and Kim did get the Nobel Peace Prize for it, so what? It’s meant as a reward for saints, but it works just as well as bait for scoundrels.
(The writer is an independent journalist)
- K’taka CM plants paddy saplings in solidarity with agriculturists 12 Aug 2018 | Kestur Vasuki | in Sunday Pioneer
- Vibrant Gujarat Summit to be held with theme ‘Shaping A New India’ from Jan 18 to 20 12 Aug 2018 | PNS | in Sunday Pioneer
- Hardik Patel, two Cong MLAs detained before taking ‘Jal Samadhi’ 12 Aug 2018 | PNS | in Sunday Pioneer
- Rain subsides but situation still serious in Kerala 12 Aug 2018 | VR Jayaraj | in Sunday Pioneer
- Brajesh’s son detained, CBI orders fresh digging 12 Aug 2018 | PNS | in Sunday Pioneer
- Jammu will take up arms if Art 35-A revoked: BJP MLA 12 Aug 2018 | Mohit Kandhari | in Sunday Pioneer
- Modi: Society that doesn’t innovate will stagnate 12 Aug 2018 | TN RAGHUNATHA | in Sunday Pioneer
- RaGa denied permission to visit Osmania 12 Aug 2018 | Omer Farooq | in Sunday Pioneer
- Rajnath slams Rahul’s ‘chipko abhiyan’ in LS 12 Aug 2018 | Biswajeet Banerjee/ Prakash Arya | in Sunday Pioneer
- Delhi statehood: AAP’s Gopal Rai seeks appointment with PM Modi 12 Aug 2018 | PNS | in Sunday Pioneer
STATE EDITIONSView All
15 Aug 2018 | Staff Reporter | Raipur
State of Chhattisgarh is moving faster from malnutrition to normal. But on the path, to achieve the target cooperation of all is required, said women and child development minister Ramsheela Sahu...