SC rejects CBI submission that Kejriwal be taken to trial court with plea seeking bail

| | New Delhi
  • 0

SC rejects CBI submission that Kejriwal be taken to trial court with plea seeking bail

Saturday, 14 September 2024 | Staff Reporter | New Delhi

The Supreme Court on Friday rejected the CBI's submission that Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal should be sent to the trial court with his plea seeking bail in the corruption case lodged by the agency in connection with the excise policy 'scam'.

The top court said that generally, the trial court should consider the prayer seeking bail once a charge sheet is filed as the material that an investigating authority may have been able to procure would undoubtedly facilitate that court to form a prima facie opinion on the gravity of the offence and the degree of involvement of the accused.

A bench of Justices Surya Kant and Ujjal Bhuyan, however, said there can be no straitjacket formula which enumerates that every case concerning the consideration of bail should depend upon the filing of a charge sheet.

Each case ought to be assessed on its own merits, recognising that no one-size-fits-all formula exists for determining bail, it said.

The top court said an undertrial should, ordinarily, first approach the trial court for bail, as this process not only provides the accused an opportunity for initial relief but also allows the high court to serve as a secondary avenue if the trial court denies bail for inadequate reasons.

"However, superior courts should adhere to this procedural recourse from the outset. If an accused approaches the high court directly without first seeking relief from the trial court, it is generally appropriate for the high court to redirect them to the trial court at the threshold.

"Nevertheless, if there are significant delays following notice, it may not be prudent to relegate the matter to the trial court at a later stage. Bail being closely tied to personal liberty, such claims should be adjudicated promptly on their merits, rather than oscillating between courts on mere procedural technicalities," Justice Kant said in his 27-page judgment.

Additional Solicitor General S V Raju, appearing for the CBI, had argued that Kejriwal should be relegated to the trial court as he approached the high court directly for bail.Raju urged that Kejriwal should not be granted any special treatment merely because of the position of power he holds or his political stature.

He canvassed that Kejriwal deserves to be treated like any other undertrial and, hence, he must first approach the trial court for bail.The apex court said the issue was more or less academic in the instant case as the high court did not relegate Kejriwal to the trial court at the preliminary stage.

"Since notice was issued and the parties were apparently heard on merits by the high court, we do not deem it necessary at this stage to relegate the appellant to the trial court even though filing of a charge sheet is a change in the circumstances," Justice Kant said.

Justice Bhuyan, who wrote a separate 33-page judgment, wrote that if the high court thought of remanding Kejriwal to the trial court, it could have done so at the threshold itself.

"After issuing notice, after hearing the parties at length and after reserving the judgment for about a week, the above order was passed by the high court. Though couched in a language which appears to be in favour of the appellant, in practical terms it has only resulted in prolonging the incarceration of the appellant for a far longer period, impacting his personal liberty," Justice Bhuyan said.

The top court granted bail to Kejriwal in the corruption case, saying prolonged incarceration amounts to unjust deprivation of liberty. According to the CBI and the ED, irregularities were committed while modifying the excise policy and undue favours extended to licence holders.

State Editions

Outsourced govt employees fail to protest due to police action

03 October 2024 | Staff Reporter | Bhopal

Sitaram Adivasi adjusted in Sahariya Authority, relief to Rawat

03 October 2024 | Girish Sharma | Bhopal

Miscreant fails to snatch hand-bag, mobile phone, caught

03 October 2024 | Staff Reporter | Bhopal

23 from the State stranded in Nepal being rescued: CM

03 October 2024 | Staff Reporter | Bhopal

BHEL celebrates Gandhi Jayanti

03 October 2024 | PNS | Bhopal

AIIMS Bhopal launches ‘HBV Safe @ AIIMS Bhopal’ digital portal

03 October 2024 | Staff Reporter | Bhopal

Sunday Edition

Durga puja | A symphony of tradition and transformation

29 September 2024 | Gyaneshwar Dayal | Agenda

A Taste of Home Away from Home

29 September 2024 | SAKSHI PRIYA | Agenda

Sip the Essence of Asia: A Unique Beverages Experience

29 September 2024 | Sharmila Chand | Agenda

Moscow | A Journey Through Time: From Soviet Shadows to Modern Marvels

29 September 2024 | Gyaneshwar Dayal | Agenda

The tuning fork | Actions Have Corresponding Consequences

29 September 2024 | C V Srikanth | Agenda

Nurpur | A journey through hidden forts and spiritual treasures

22 September 2024 | Aditi Sharma | Agenda